Education Atlas

How Knowledge Is Built
Sign In
Text size
100%
Theme
Learning Theory and Concepts

Assertive Discipline

Behaviorist and Cognitive Processing Theories

Assertive discipline is a classroom-management model developed by the American educators Lee Canter and Marlene Canter and presented in their 1976 book Assertive Discipline: A Take-Charge Approach for Today's Educator, built on the claim that a teacher has both the right and the responsibility to determine and enforce the behavior needed for a classroom to run effectively, and that this authority should be exercised assertively rather than passively or hostilely. The model calls for a teacher to state a small number of clear, specific classroom rules at the start of the year, to respond to rule-following with consistent positive recognition and to rule-breaking with a predictable, escalating sequence of consequences that the teacher applies calmly and without anger every time a rule is broken, so that students learn the connection between their choices and the outcomes that follow. The Canters also described specific assertive-response techniques, including the broken record technique, calmly repeating a stated expectation without being drawn into an argument or excuse, as an alternative to either ignoring misbehavior or reacting with hostility. The model was highly influential in American classroom-management training from the late 1970s onward, and was also criticized by later scholars as overly reliant on external, teacher-imposed control rather than helping students develop internal self-discipline.

Facts
Core Claim
Assertive discipline is a classroom-management model developed by Lee and Marlene Canter that directs teachers to state clear behavioral expectations, give positive recognition when students meet them, and apply consistent consequences when they do not. 1
Origin Year
1976 1
FAQs

Why do some educators criticize assertive discipline?

Critics say its simplicity and stress on external control harm students and teachers; Lee Canter replies that it teaches children responsibility.

Critics contend that assertive discipline is harmful to students and teachers precisely because of its apparent simplicity, and describe it as a control-oriented system of rules and penalties stressing compliance, sanctions and external motivation. Lee Canter, who developed the model with Marlene Canter, answers that the point is teaching children responsibility, and that children learn it by being told exactly what is expected of them.
Sources
1. Order in the Classroom (Education Week)
Education WeekEducation Week, Order in the Classroom, 1990
Quote, Education Week, Order in the Classroom, 1990
Canter and his wife, Marlene, a former special-education teacher, published Assertive Discipline: A Take-Charge Approach For Today's Educator in 1976.
View the Source
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.